If I buy a Porsche 911, should I buy a Carrera or Carrera S?

Porsche 911 (992 type)
Reviews & Test Rides

Porsche 911 Carrera or Carrera S

Today I would like to share with you a question I received on my blog earlier and my husband's response to it.

I'm currently planning on buying a 992.I am torn between Carrera and Carrera S.I am transferring from Macan gts and do not own any other model.
You speak highly of the bare-bones Carrera on your blog, but can you tell us a little more about the difference between the Carrera and the Carrera S?

This was the case.

This person had been a configurator and provided an estimate as well.A plain Carrera, including options, costs about 18 million yen, while a Carrera S costs about 20.5 million yen.This was the case.

She consulted our blog to get advice from her husband, who has experience with various models, because of the budget.

But a 911 is so expensive...! My husband's first Porsche, a 981 Boxster GTS, was priced at less than 10 million yen (including options) for a new car.

What, 10 million yen for a car! Why! That's too expensive! You could do so many other things with 10 million yen!

But now I thought, "Compared to the 911, the Boxster GTS is a pretty good deal.I think, "I've lost my senses about cars..." and so on. I have completely lost my senses when it comes to cars....

Is a plain 911 more than enough for Japanese roads?

The beginning of the "Carrera or Carrera S?In response to the question, "What is the best way to get a job?", I asked my husband, and he responded as follows.

My husband is a plain 911 guesser.

In terms of low-speed torque and ease of handling around town, the bare-bones Carrera is easier to handle. In comparison, the Carrera S may feel like it needs a little more breathing room to pick up torque in town.

S is smoother than the bare S in terms of ride comfort.I think it's fine.

I don't think I am largely wrong about these things, as various Porsche drivers I know say the same thing.

As for speed, the bare minimum is sufficient on Japanese roads.Acceleration when merging out of a toll booth on the highway is also unquestionably fast. As for the sense of power in the high-rpm range.It is hard to tell the difference between the bare S and the S unless you compare acceleration above around 180 km/h or so.And although the S has more power, there are almost no situations where it can be demonstrated on public roads in Japan.

As for circuit driving, when I drove the 992 (cabriolet) on the Fuji Speedway last year, it was more than fast enough, and the acceleration in the straight line was amazing. The way the engine runs is so powerful that it is hard to believe that it is a turbo engine.If the driver presses down deeply on the accelerator pedal in Sport Plus mode, the engine will burst through the red zone of 7,400 rpm and reach 8,000 rpm at once.

Porsche 911 (992)

I've also driven a 992 Carrera 4S on the track, butIt was certainly even faster, but I didn't find the difference that overwhelming.is honest. To be stingy, my sensibilities did not perceive a difference of about 3 million yen in price difference.

After driving on various roads with the bare 992, I was like, "I'm not going to be able to do that.If you run in Japan, you'll be more than satisfied with the bare bones.I feel that it is the best way to go. So, if you are not sure whether to buy a Carrera or a Carrera S, than consider the difference in power feel.S for comfort, and "plain" for ease of use around town.It might be better to think of it as.

If you still want to emphasize "power, speed, and hierarchy,"One option is to wait until the GTS is released.I think. As for resale, looking at previous 911s, the GTS is likely to be higher.

This was the case.

The person who asked this question told us that he had made an appointment to test drive a bare 911 at a dealer.

Next page→About the plain goodness after knowing the turbo model

Mina.

Mother of three children, and the owner of the Porsche blog "A Porsche Came to Our House". Until a few years ago, I was not interested in cars at all, but when my husband bought a Porsche, I became...

Profile

Follow me if you like this blog!

Close Comment
  • Comment ( 4 )

  • Trackbacks are closed.

  1. tenoned part of a wooden joint (in construction)

    Thank you for your always enjoyable articles.
    When I test drove the base grade, I found it a little too stiff for me.

    I was used to the ride quality of the Carrera s, and also because the suspension had not been acclimated after about 1000 km of test driving.
    There may be some, but I had the impression that it picked up small bumps on the road surface in great detail.
    Forgot to look at the tire brands.
    As your husband said, I guess it depends on what kind of ride you want.

    Off topic, but the 981GTS Boxster rides like a champ!
    The tires are the newer, more recent P Zero's, but nothing like the old, unimpressive P Zero's!

    I also wore Michelin 4s on my 991, and as much as I like them, I have the impression that the P Zero is getting better.

    • Mina.Mina.

      Mr. Tomozo.
      Thank you for everything!

      >When I test drove the base grade, I felt it was a little too stiff for me.
      It sure is pretty stiff...!
      My wife and I like the firmness, but still, the bare-bones 992 that was just delivered to us.
      I thought, "This is too hard, this is a little too hard.

      As I rode it, it became smoother and now I think it has mellowed a lot.

      Tires, the latest from P Zero is that good!
      Tires are evolving every day!

  2. Tak Kite

    As I have commented before, I am ordering a 992 bare Carrera. The reason I went with the bare car is simple: the power of the S is completely unnecessary on public roads in Japan, and the price is too high. If I could afford the S, I would get a cabriolet before that (I ended up with a coupe, but instead? I added a glass sunroof!) ). How is the ride? I think the bare bones with standard 19/20 wheels rides better than the 20/21 S. This is my first Porsche in my life, and I actually ordered a 992 without ever test driving one, trusting the perfection of the 992. And now that the infection numbers have subsided a bit, I finally went to PC yesterday and test drove a bare-bones Carrera. I only drove it around town for a short time, but I think it was comfortable. My wife also drove it and said it was too normal to drive, not scary at all. In fact, sports cars are dangerous, there is no way I can drive one! It's a big step forward from where I was saying "sports cars are dangerous, there's no way I can drive one! I am looking forward to the bare-bones Carrera and delivery of the car in 6 months.

    • Mina.Mina.

      Mr. Tak Kite
      Thank you!

      Indeed, S is really expensive...
      I thought it was tremendous...over 20 million yen with options.

      That sunroof on the coupe is soooo nice!

      >My wife drove it and said it was too normal and not scary at all.
      Oh yes!
      I, too, had stubbornly refused to drive a sports car until I drove a Porsche.
      Once I drove it, I was surprised to find that I could drive it as I wanted and feel safe.

      I'm looking forward to taking delivery of your car!
      I hope that by then Corona will be calmer than it is now and we can go for a drive.

      I would be very happy if you could tell me more about your impressions of the car when it is delivered.