[Live Stream Summary] Vol.92: If You Could Keep Only One Porsche, Which Would You Choose? The Ultimate Decision Discussed

タイカン ターボGT
Live Streaming

This is a summary article of the recent live stream radio show “Welcome Home, PORSCHE.”
Feel free to enjoy it during your commute, school runs, or as a driving companion inside your Porsche.
If you like the content, please give us a thumbs up and subscribe to the channel!

Main Topics and Highlights

Theme of the Episode: If You Could Keep Only One Porsche, Which Would You Choose? [00:16]

  • First broadcast in two weeks. This time, the discussion centered on the ultimate choice: which single Porsche to keep.
  • Premise: only one Porsche in the household, assuming a family of a couple plus children.
  • Not considering having a separate family car—truly the one and only Porsche.

Viewer’s Pick: The Versatility of the 981 Boxster GTS [00:36]

  • A viewer suggested the 981 Boxster GTS, praising its comfortable ride and all-around capability.
  • Its ride height is reasonable, so with some care at gas stations, scraping is avoidable.
  • Quiet cruising is possible, yet it delivers power when you push it—ideal for touring without fatigue.
  • The host himself logged 15,000 km in the first six months, using it for commuting and errands.

Considering the 911 Carrera T [05:29]

  • Another viewer recommended returning to basics with the Carrera T, realistically the 992 pre- or post-facelift.
  • Sporty yet balanced enough to avoid discomfort in daily use.
  • Adding rear seats makes it somewhat family-friendly; the main challenge is the low ride height.
  • With a lift-up system, everyday usability improves significantly.

The Overwhelming Support for the Taycan [06:56]

  • A viewer with a family of four chose the Taycan as their ultimate single Porsche.
  • The host agreed, saying, “If it were now, it would be the Taycan” due to its exceptional versatility.
  • Even after driving the latest 911, the host felt the Taycan was the better buy.
  • The driving feel is on a completely different level—not your typical sedan experience.

Comparing the Taycan Turbo GT and Taycan 4S [13:13]

  • Hiro and Mina compared the Taycan Turbo GT and 4S on a round trip to Okayama.
  • The Turbo GT is “too much” in the best way—handling, sound, and bucket seats are in a league of their own.
  • It feels like a completely different car from the 4S, which explains why the Turbo GT doesn’t carry the Taycan nameplate.
  • The Turbo GT should be considered a standalone model due to its distinct character.

The Charm of the Early 997 Turbo Manual [16:06]

  • A viewer suggested the early 997 Turbo with a manual transmission.
  • The 997 and 996 generations are easier to drive and lack the clinical feel of modern Porsches.
  • They offer a “human” and “automotive” feel, with an engine character close to the GT3.
  • The combination of a manual and 997 Turbo is highly appealing.

Returning to the Classic 911 Carrera [18:00]

  • A viewer said that for two people, the 911 Carrera remains the best choice.
  • Many Porsche enthusiasts eventually settle on the Carrera after exploring other models.
  • Typically, owners start with a Carrera, move on to GT3 or GTS, but often return to the Carrera.
  • It offers excellent balance for all situations—city, highway, track, and mountain roads.

The Panamera as a Choice [20:01]

  • A viewer chose the Panamera, highlighting it as the sportiest 4-5 seater Porsche aside from the Taycan.
  • It’s the closest to a 911 in the Porsche lineup, excluding the Taycan.
  • On the highway, it exudes a commanding presence—the “king” vibe—with a stylish exterior.
  • The Panamera Turbo offers remarkable stability even in rain, with agility that belies its size.

The Perfect Balance of the 991.1 Carrera 4S [23:28]

  • A viewer currently drives a 991 early Carrera 4S PDK and recommends it.
  • For a couple, the 911 is sufficient, and the all-wheel drive makes daily driving and touring powerful and enjoyable.
  • The 4S strikes a perfect balance without being too aggressive; the 4 GTS can sometimes feel too intense.
  • Another viewer agreed that the 991.1 Carrera 4 is a “correct” choice.

Practicality of the Taycan Cross Turismo [27:24]

  • A viewer with a family of four also voted for the Taycan Cross Turismo.
  • The Cross Turismo looks cool and has a sportier vibe.
  • Adding the off-road package changes its character completely, raising ride height and enabling all-terrain driving.
  • It’s practical for snowy roads, such as ski trips.

The Unique Appeal of the 911 T Cabriolet [28:17]

  • A viewer is ordering a 911 T Cabriolet: open-top, manual, 4-seater.
  • Such a combination is extremely rare among sports cars.
  • However, the rear seats in the Cabriolet have very upright backrests, which may be uncomfortable for long rides.

Host’s Choice: Taycan Turbo or Turbo GT [34:30]

  • Hiro’s conclusion is either a Taycan variant or a 911 Turbo.
  • Considering practicality, the Taycan Turbo GT (standard, not Weissach) or 911 Turbo are top picks.
  • If reliability and breakdown risk are ignored, the tiptronic 996 or 997 Turbo also have strong appeal.
  • Mina prefers the Taycan Turbo Cross Turismo, loving highway driving and the electric acceleration feel.

Advice on Switching to a 718 Spider Manual [36:45]

  • A viewer asked about switching from a 991.1 GTS Cabriolet to a 718 Spider manual.
  • Hiro’s advice: “You will definitely regret it.” You lose the 991.1’s iconic engine sound.
  • The 718’s 4L NA engine delivers torque from low revs, feeling more like a turbo than a naturally aspirated engine, unlike the 991.1’s rev-happy character.
  • If you love the design and want it no matter what, go for it—but if engine sound matters, you’ll regret it.
  • Several people known to the host have switched to the 718 Spider and then returned to 991 or 981 models.

Comparing with Tesla: Model 3 Performance [40:09]

  • A viewer said if forced to pick only one car, it might be the Tesla Model 3 Performance, but they’re not ready for that yet.
  • The host agreed that without the Porsche brand restriction, the Model 3 Performance could be the choice.
  • It offers track-level speed, ultra-comfortable and quiet daily driving.
  • With Full Self-Driving (FSD), it’s like having a personal chauffeur—akin to a taxi driver at your service.

Tesla Sales and Autonomous Driving Updates [48:24]

  • A viewer shared that Tesla is expected to outsell Nissan in EV sales this year in Japan.
  • Tesla announced the Model Y as the best-selling electric vehicle in Japan.
  • Next year, Tesla Owners Club Japan will host an EV event allowing Japanese EV makers to exhibit.
  • Delivery schedules are tight, with some deliveries pushed from late September to mid-October.

Interior Design of the New Cayenne EV [50:52]

  • News about the new Cayenne EV’s interior featuring three screens.
  • Hiro’s opinion: “Porsche users don’t want that. Why focus on this?”
  • It’s unclear why Porsche invests in infotainment when it doesn’t even offer autonomous driving.
  • Some suggest reviving analog instruments like the classic 5-gauge cluster to boost sales.
  • Fixing current infotainment glitches should come before adding new features.

Next Episode Preview: What Is Porsche’s Best Engine? [57:01]

  • A viewer proposed the next theme: “What is the best 911 engine?”
  • The host acknowledged it’s an advanced topic but agreed to cover it next time.
  • Discussion will include not only the 911 but also Boxster and Cayman engines.
  • Panamera’s V8 might also be considered.

Hiro

Minaの夫です。 ファッションやステータスシンボルのためにクルマは乗りません。 運転して楽しく、工業製品として優れ、作り手の意思が感じられるようなクルマを好んで乗ります。長距離ツーリングをこよなく愛し、「クルマは走らせてナンボ」と思ってます。休日には日本全国を愛車で旅しています。 ブログでは主に試乗レポートやツーリング記などを執筆しています。またブログのシステム周りやチューニングなども担当しています。

Profile

このブログが気に入ったらフォローしてね!

コメントを閉じる
  • Comment ( 0 )

  • Trackbacks are closed.

  1. No comments yet.